PHL 3305 Lecture 7

« previous | Friday, September 13, 2019 | next »

When reading,

• the reader is the most important stuff to which to pay attention
• the text will provide commentary

Read 3 times (Dr. Lehman promises they'll be short!)

1. Get a general sense of what's going on
2. Divide the reading into 2-4 components/parts to find how the parts relate to each other
3. Read to let nothing get past you
   • terms and definitions
   • syllogisms
   • make notes of anything that is confusing

For Next Time

• Give primacy to the General Introduction from the Logic Text

Newman, Cont'd

• Central thesis: Knowledge is its own end (versus knowledge as a utility)

Newman claims:

• Knowledge has no bearing on one's beliefs, actions, or will
  • knowledge should be morality-agnostic

I disagree.

• Knowledge for its own sake drives a wedge between intellectual and moral formation
• Knowledge itself becomes the moral code
• Separating intellect from morals removes unity of Catholic liberal education
• Knowledge forms foundation of morality
  • to become prudent, one has to know what prudence looks like

We seek the beauty that is the perfection of the intellect:

There is a physical beauty and a moral: there is a beauty of person, there is a beauty of our moral being, which is natural virtue; and in like manner there is a beauty, there is a perfection, of the intellect.

Only the Lover Sings

Josef Pieper

Like in the Republic by Plato, music plays a huge role in the formation of the soul

• Music is more than just what you listen to: it is metaphorical of the harmony/balance/order of everything