MATH 409 Lecture 22

From Notes
Jump to navigation Jump to search

« previous | Tuesday, November 19, 2013 | next »

Begin Exam 3 content
Lecture Slides

Improper Riemann Integrals

If a function f:[a,b]→ℝ is integrable on [a,b], then the function F(x)=∫axf(t)dt is well-defined and continuous on [a,b]. In particular, F(c)→F(b) as c→b−, that is,

∫abf(x)dx=limc→b+∫acf(x)dx

Now suppose f is defined on the semi-open interval J=[a,b) and is integrable on any closed interval [c,d]⊂J (such a function is called locally integrable on J). Then all integrals in the rgiht-hand side above are defined and the limit might exist even if f is not integrable on [a,b].

If this is the case, then f is called improperly integrable on J, and the limit is called the (improper) integral of f on [a,b).

Similar definition for (a,b]: take limit as c→a+.


Precise Definition. A function f:(a,b)→ℝ is called improperly integrable on the open interval (a,b) if for some (and then for any) c∈(a,b) it is improperly integrable on semi-open intervals (a,c] and [c,b). The integral of f is defined by

∫abf(x)dx=∫acf(x)dx+∫cbf(x)dx

Properties

Suppose a function f is locally integrable on a semi-open interval J=[a,b) or J=(a,b]. Then there are two possible obstructions for f to be integrable on [a,b]:

  1. the function f is not bounded on J as we approach the open endpoint,
  2. The interval J is not bounded: open endpoint might be infinity.


Since an improper Riemann integral is a limit of proper integrals, the properties of improper integrals are analogous to those of proper integrals (and derived using limit theorems).

Theorem. Let f:[a,b)→ℝ be integrable on any closed interval [a1,b1]⊂[a,b). Given c∈(a,b), the function f is improperly integrable on [c,b) if and only if it is improperly integrable on [a,b). In the case of integrability,

∫abf(x)dx=∫acf(x)dx+∫cbf(x)dx

Sketch of proof. Choos d∈(c,b). We have the following equality involving proper Riemann integrals:

∫adf(x)dx=∫acf(x)dx+∫cdf(x)dx

The theorem is proved by taking the limit as d→b−.

quod erat demonstrandum


Theorem. Suppose that a function f:(a,b)→ℝ is integrable on any closed interval [c,d]⊂(a,b). Given a number I∈ℝ, the following conditions are equivalent:

  1. for some c∈(a,b), the function f is improperly integrable on (a,c] and [c,b) and ∫acf(x)dx+∫cbf(x)dx=I
  2. for every c∈(a,b), the function f is improperly integrable on (a,c] and [c,b) and ∫acf(x)dx+∫cbf(x)dx=I
  3. for every c∈(a,b), the function f is improperly integrable on (a,c] and ∫acf(x)dx→I as c→b−
  4. for every c∈(a,b), the function f is improperly integrable on [c,b) and ∫cbf(x)dx→I as c→a+

In view of the previous theorem, the integral does not depend on c. It can also be computed as a repeated limit:

∫abf(x)dx=limd→b−(limc→a+∫cdf(x)dx)=limc→a+(limd→b−∫cdf(x)dx)

Finally, the integral can be computed as a double limit (i.e., the limit of a function of two variables):

∫abf(x)dx=limc→a+d→b−∫cdf(x)dx


If a function f is integrable on a closed interval [a,b] or improperly integrable on one of the semi-open intervals [a,b) and (a,b], then it is also improperly integrable on the open interval (a,b) with the same value of the integral.


If functions f,g are improperly integrable on (a,b), then for any α,β∈ℝ, the linear combination αf+βg is also improperly integrable on (a,b) and

∫ab(αf(x)+βg(x))dx=α∫abf(x)dx+β∫abg(x)dx


Suppose a function f:(a,b)→ℝ is locally integrable and has an antiderivative F. Then f is improperly integrable on (a,b) if and only if F(x) has finite limits as x→a+ and as x→b−, in which case

∫abf(x)dx=limx→b−F(x)−limx→a+F(x)


Comparison Theorems for Improper Integrals

Theorem 1. Suppose that functions f,g are improperly integrable on (a,b). If f(x)≤g(x) for all x∈(a,b), then

∫abf(x)dx≤∫abf(x)dx


Theorem 2. Suppose that functions f,g are locally integrable on (a,b). If the function g is improperly integrable on (a,b) and 0≤f(x)≤g(x) for all x∈(a,b), then f is also improperly integrable on (a,b).

Note: This is the first theorem in which we can prove integrability of a function without actually computing its integral or taking an antiderivative. (not all functions have antiderivatives, but are still integrable)


Theorem 3. Suppose that functions f,g,h are locally integrable on (a,b). If the functions g,h are improperly integrable on (a,b) and h(x)≤f(x)≤g(x) for all x∈(a,b), then f is also improperly integrable on (a,b) and

∫abh(x)dx≤∫abf(x)dx≤∫abg(x)dx
Note: This theorem is derived from theorems 1 and 2. Also, h and g need not be identical.


Examples

1x is improperly integrable on (0,1].

∫011xdx=limc→0+∫c11xdx=limc→0+2x|x=c1=limc→0+(2−2c)=2

x−2 is improperly integrable on [1,∞).

∫1∞=limc→+∞∫1cx−2dx=limc→+∞−x−1|x=1c=limc→+∞(1−c−1)=1

f(x)=x−2 is not improperly integrable on (0,∞).

Indeed the antiderivative of f is F(x)=−x−1, which has a finite limit as x→∞, but diverges to infinity as x→0+.

g(x)=x−2cos⁡x is improperly integrable on [1,∞).

This function has no nice antiderivative. Instead, we shall use the "squeeze theorem" for improper integrals. We have −f(x)≤g(x)≤f(x)=x−2 for all x≥1 (f is from the previous example). Since f is improperly integrable on [1,∞), it follows that −f is also improperly integrable on [1,∞). By the Comparison Theorem for improper integrals, the function g is improperly integrable on [1,∞) as well.

f(x)=e−x is improperly integrable on [0,∞).

Indeed, the antiderivative of the function is −e−x, which has a finite limit as x→+∞.

g(x)=e−x2 is improperly integrable on (−∞,∞).

Similar to above, there is no nice antiderivative of this function, but this formula shows up all the time in statistics.

We have 0≤g(x)≤f(x)=e−x for all x≥1. Since f is improperly integrable on [0,∞), it follows that g is improperly integrable on [1,∞). Since g is even, g(−x)=g(x), it follows that g is also improperly integrable on (−∞,−1]. Finally, g is properly integrable on [−1,1].

f(x)=x−1sin⁡x is improperly integrable on [1,∞).

In the cos⁡x example above, we used the comparison theorem. This will not work here because the antiderivative of x−1 is ln⁡x, which has no limit as x→∞. To show improper integrability, we integrate by parts:

∫1cx−1cos⁡xdx=−∫1cx−1d(cos⁡x)=−x−1cos⁡x|x=1c+∫1ccos⁡xd(x−1)=cos⁡1−c−1cos⁡c−∫1cx−2cos⁡xdx

Since the function g(x)=x−2cos⁡x is improperly integrable on [1,∞) and c−1cos⁡c→0 as c→∞, it follows that f is improperly integrable on [1,∞).


Absolute Integrability

Definition. A funciton f:(a,b)→ℝ is called absolutely integrable on (a,b) if f is locally integrable on (a,b) and |f| is improperly integrable on (a,b).

Theorem. If a function f is absolutely integrable on (a,b), then it is also improperly integrable on (a,b) and

|∫abf(x)dx|≤∫ab|f(x)|dx

Proof. Since |f| is improperly integrable on (a,b), so is −|f|. Clearly, −|f(x)|≤f(x)≤|f(x)| for all x∈(a,b). By the Comparison Theorems for improper integrals, the function f is improperly integrable on (a,b) and

−∫ab|f(x)|dx≤∫abf(x)dx≤∫ab|f(x)|dx
quod erat demonstrandum


Examples

For any nonnegataive function, the absolute integrability is equivalent to improper integrability.

In particular,

  • The function f1(x)=x−2 is absolutely integrable on [1,∞) and is not on (0,∞).
  • The function f2=1x is absolutely integrable on (0,1).
  • The function f3(x)=e−x2 is absolutely integrable on (−∞,∞)

The function f(x)=e−x2sin⁡x is absolutely integrable on (−∞,∞)

Indeed, the function f is locally integrable on (−∞,∞), a function g(x)=e−x2 is improperly integrable on (−∞,∞), and |f(x)|≤g(x) for all x∈ℝ

Counterexamples

The function f(x)={1x∈ℚ−1x∈ℝ∖ℚ is not absolutely integrable on (0,1):

Indeed, the function f is not locally integrable on (0,1). At the same time, the function |f| is constant and hence (properly) integrable on (0,1).

f(x)=x−1sin⁡x is not absolutely integrable on [1,∞).

For any n∈ℕ,

∫nπ(n+1)π|f(x)|dx≥∫nπ(n+1)π|sin⁡x|(n+1)πdx=1(n+1)π∫0πsin⁡xdx=2(n+1)π≥1nπ≥1π∫nπ(n+1)π1xdx

It remains to notice that g(x)=1x is not improperly integrable on [π,∞).

Main idea: The function f behaves similarly to x−1, so the improper integral on [1,∞) does not exist.